Branding

Your Brand Is Alive. Is It Trying to Please Everyone?

by Louise Goodthorp
8 min read
Branding
Louise and her dog

Does your brand know what it’s willing to say no to?

Dear Reader,

Time is precious. We can only spend it once. So in light of you reading this newsletter right now… in amongst a back-to-back diary and ever-growing to-do list… let’s make your next five minutes worth it. 

Let’s talk about brand; my favourite topic. (Well, that or dogs. You can happily get me on either topic.)

But, have you stopped lately to think about your brand? To really think about it, in the eyes of your audience. 

What does it stand for? Who is it actually for? 

And, is the hard work you’re doing each day contributing to your brand thriving, or just surviving? 

Times are kinda complicated. The digital, economic, political, social and literal climate that our brands exist in make for temperamental stability and changeable dynamics, month to month..

So whether your business is built for other businesses, or you serve the consumer market, knowing what you stand for, what your vision is and what the strategy is to get there, are the things that make the difference in today’s messy world. 

And, if you can confidently say you know the answer to all those things – why you exist… what you’re working towards… and how you’re going to get there – kudos to you! It’s definitely do-able, it’s just not easy.

Your brand is alive

Your business is a living, breathing thing. From operations, to people and culture, to customer services, to product development… what you do doesn’t stop, in order to give you time to think. 

Strategy and delivery are two tracks running alongside each other – you can’t pause one to give you the headspace for the other.

How do we know we’re on the right path?

With brand, you can’t be all things to all people. That’s not how it works – not for brands, and not for people either. 

Knowing what you are, and what you’re not, matter more than ever. 

Someone literally asked me today, ‘what is a brand proposition?’ – I told them it’s the single, most succinct statement that tells me why I should choose you over another brand. Not the version that sounds good in a boardroom. Not the version your competitors could claim word-for-word if you swapped the logo. What’s the one thing that’s actually, unmistakably, undeniably you.

And if there’s one thing separating the brands people love from the brands people scroll past, it’s authenticity. Not as a buzzword, but as a discipline.

People know what ‘good’ looks like

Here’s the thing nobody tells you when you’re building a brand: authenticity isn’t about being raw, unfiltered or relentlessly ‘real’. It’s not about trying to be cool for the sake of it or doing something ‘out there’ just to get attention, with no meaning or purpose behind the big hurrah. It’s simpler and harder than that. It’s the alignment between what you say and what you do, consistently, across every touchpoint, every day – not just when a campaign calls for it.

Say one thing on your socials or on your company website and do another in your customer experience, and people notice. 

People are exposed to and engaging with brands all day every day – they know what good looks like. Phones. Cars. Clothes. Food. Radio stations. Apps. Everything. Who people choose to give their time and money to, matters more than ever. People need to know what you stand for, what you offer – and whether it’s something they’re willing to pay for, in whatever currency, time and time again.

Trying to please everyone pleases no one

This is the trap so many businesses fall into: broadening the message to avoid alienating anyone, and in doing so, saying nothing that actually resonates.

We’ve all watched rebrands land badly not because the new logo wasn’t everyone’s cup of tea, but because the shift felt emotionally disconnected from what people already believed about the brand. Either the story didn’t match the substance or the business tried tried to reposition too far ahead of what customers held dear about the brand. 

Compare that to brands willing to take a clear position and hold it. Burberry’s recent immersive fashion week activation – built around a fantastical “Burberry knight” narrative – didn’t try to be everything to everyone. It leaned hard into a specific, theatrical, unmistakably Burberry world, and it paid off in the kind of earned attention money can’t buy. That’s what conviction looks like when it’s backed by genuine brand substance.

The de-influencing effect

There’s another shift worth naming: audiences are actively rewarding brands – and creators – who admit what a product doesn’t do well, or who it’s not right for. Counterintuitive, I know. But that honesty is exactly what builds the credibility that makes the rest of the message believable. Perfect, polished, no-flaws-here brand messaging is starting to read as a red flag, not reassurance.

So, how’s your brand’s health, really?

If you’re not sure your proposition would survive being said out loud, in one sentence, to a stranger, that’s your starting point to focus on in rebuilding your brand narrative. 

Because here’s the truth: your brand proposition isn’t a tagline. It’s a promise your entire business has to be willing to keep, on the good days and the difficult ones, when nobody’s watching or when everybody is watching. 

The businesses winning right now aren’t the loudest, or the most polished, or the most relentlessly on-trend. They’re the ones who know exactly what they stand for – and have the discipline to say no to everything that isn’t that.

So when you get your next 5 minutes amongst the madness of your working week, think: does your brand know what it’s willing to say no to?

If you’re not sure, that’s the exact thing I love to help you get to the bottom of.

Your Brand Is Alive. Is It Trying to Please Everyone?

We don’t want briefs.
We want problems.
That’s where the magic happens.

StrategiQ Full Awards List
2025
UK Search Awards
Best low budget campaign (PPC): Large
UK Search Awards
Best use of search – B2B (PPC): Large
The Drum Awards
Brand / Design Nominee
European Search Awards
Best Low Budget Campaign (SEO)
2024
WP Engine APP
Committed to Give Back
UK Search Awards
Best use of AI in Search
UK Search Awards
Best low budget campaign (SEO): Large
UK Search Awards
Best use of search – Travel / Leisure (PPC): Large
Dotdigital Partner Awards
Retail Service Partner of the Year
DevelopHER Awards
Inspiration Award
UK Dev Awards
Rising Star
UK Dev Awards
Fintech Website
UK Dev Awards
Third Sector Website
Campaign Best Places to Work
26/100
UK Dev Awards
Retail/Ecommerce Website
UK Company Culture Awards
Best HR Tool
Sunday Times' 100 Best Places to Work
Small Organisations Category
2023
DevelopHER Awards
Digital Marketer of the Year
UK Dev Awards
Best Third Sector Website
UK Dev Awards
UX Award for StrategiQ
UK Paid Media Awards
Best Use of Linkedin Ads
UK Paid Media Awards
Paid Media Agency Led Campaign Of The Year
European Paid Media Awards
Best Use of Linkedin Ads
UK Agency Awards
Best Culture Transformation Initiative
UK Search Awards
Best Use of Search (Travel)
Social Media Awards
Best Use of Instagram
Social Media Awards
Best Use of Linkedin
Social Media Awards
Best Audience Engagement Campaign
DevelopHER Awards
Emerging Talent
UK Search Awards
Best Use of Search
2022
Dotties Awards
Marketer of the Year
Elite Agency
Campaign Best Places to Work
Winner Top 50
UK Dev Awards
Project of the Year
UK Dev Awards
Travel Website of the Year
UK Dev Awards
Best Site Migration
UK Dev Awards
B2B Website of the Year
UK Paid Media Awards
Local Campaign of the Year
UK Paid Media Awards
Best Use of Attribution
UK Search Awards
Best Local Campaign (PPC) (LARGE)
UK Search Awards
Travel / Leisure (PPC) (LARGE)
UK Search Awards
Retail / Ecommerce (SEO) (LARGE)
The Drum Awards
Best Business Development Initiative
2021
UK Dev Awards
Best Migration
Campaign Best Places to Work
Winner Top 50
UK Agency Awards
Covid Response (Silver)
UK Agency Awards
Campaign Effectiveness Award (Silver)
UK Search Awards
Best Use of Search Third Sector (Silver)
UK Search Awards
Best Use of Content Marketing (Silver)
UK Search Awards
Best Large SEO Campaign
2020
Campaign Best Places to Work
Winner Top 50
Suffolk Business Awards
Business of the Year
Suffolk Business Awards
Small & Medium Business of the Year
2019
DXA Awards
Best PPC Strategy with Powertool World
Suffolk Business Awards
Best Employer
2018
Best Employers Eastern Region
Best Digital & Technology Business
UK Search Awards
Best Small Integrated Search Agency
2016
EADT Business Awards
One To Watch Award
Read
Play
Hover